In a recent blog post, I concluded with a short statement regarding my frustrations with Comcast--"I hate Comcast" was the concluding remark, just for a refresher. Curiously reading our user comments for the week, I stumbled on this:
Hi Chris,
I work for Comcast and I will be happy to offer my assistance to you. Please feel free to reach out to me if you need assistance with your service.
Thank you in advance for the opportunity!
Sincerely,
Mark C.
Comcast Executive Offices
We_Can_Help@cable.comcast.com
Crazy, huh? Comcast does quality control via blogs? Wild. I played with the idea of responding and a few days later did just that. Here is the email I crafted:
Mark C.,
You recently posted a comment on a blog I post at, www.utopianrealist.com, in response to my "I hate Comcast" remark undoubtedly. Historically my complaints have been directed at your install people...and only when I first sign up for your service. Mostly because I don't think a shred of time spent complaining will result in any change of service. Nevertheless, if the Comcast PR dept never hears of the issues, how will you know to fix them...here are a few of my questions/complaints. Perhaps you can shed some light on some of them.
Comcast promotes the "powered by fiber" even though they don't offer fiber connections straight to your home. I get that you're trying to hop on the "fiber optic" buzz word bandwagon, but you don't actually offer fiber lines directly to anyone's homes! You're deceiving potential customers. Honesty and trust are what build loyal customers, especially in this modern age.
Why does Comcast promise x Mbps down and y Mbps up, but fail to deliver? Moreover, why are certain users penalized (P2P traffic shaping) for actually using their connection. Why does Comcast oversell it's bandwidth so much? It really bothers me that users active enough online to take advantage of the bandwidth they were sold are being penalized. It's not the customer's fault if your infrastructure can't handle the traffic--you sold x Mbps, they're gonna use it. Maybe its time increase the infrastructure budget for next quarter.
And the fees!! Why am I charged a fee for a self installation? Your charging me to do my own install?
When trying to sign up for your service a couple months ago, I signed up online, where I was transfered to a live chat session. That's fine, in fact I applaud the progressive attitude towards the process. However I was told I didn't qualify for most of the packages and that promo deals were not for new customers....wait what?! I've gotten promo deals in the past...promo deals are typically to entice potential customers....I'm a potential customer...I don't follow. My parents were told the same thing.
And for comparison, I had Verizon's Fios connection for a year--the 5 Mbps down/1 Mbps up package. It was miraculous. I could download the latest Linux distro (1 GB or more) in less than an hour, without being penalized or limited. I paid $34.99/month for the first 6 months, $39.99/month after that--no ridiculous spike in cost after the promo period. How is it that I get pure, unadulterated fiber optic heaven, rated at 5 Mbps down/1 Mbps up cheaper than the intermittent, 6 Mbps down/2 Mbps up package Comcast sold me for $52.95/month. In your defense, the PowerBoost feature theoretically is a great feature, particularly for browsing--I applaud this idea as well. But if you asked me under which service web pages loaded faster, I would have to tell you Verizon...because it's the truth. Anecdotal, I know, but browsing under the Verizon Fios connection, for whatever reason, was always faster than browsing with my current Comcast Connection.
And what's this about HD content quality issues? (link)
You guys have a tough job dividing bandwidth amongst your many subscribers and people love to hate the big corporations. Nevertheless, please try to improve the quality of your service. I'm a fair man and I will admit when I'm wrong...I'm capable of reevaluating my opinion of Comcast's services. I hope this rant didn't come across as simply bitchy, and that you might use these criticisms to shape your business in the future.
Curious to hear back,
Chris
Here is the crafted-by-public-relations, customer friendly response I received, not from Mark C., but from a Frank Eliason:
Mr. Eigner.
Thank you for the feedback. Hopefully we will be able to work to improve your perception of Comcast. We do not work for the PR department, but rather for the Executive Office. In our role we work to ensure Customers have a good experience with our company, when they do not, we try to improve the experience.
I will attempt to address each of your points:
Fiber
Comcast actually has the largest fiber network in the US. Like at&t, and all major cable companies, Comcast takes the fiber to the node, which would be located near your home. From there, the signal is transmitted via coaxial cable. Verizon decided to run fiber to the home, and then transmit through coaxial cable.
Speed
Customers do usually receive the speed that they sign up for, and when they do not, I usually prefer to have this checked out. In many cases it is a technical issue that is fixable. I do understand your comments regarding network management. Comcast, like all major ISP’s does have to manage network resources to ensure we are creating the right experience for all our Customers. We are currently working with BitTorrent, Inc to develop routing techniques that improve the handling of BitTorrent files. This should help with Customers that are downloading a large number of these files.
We are also working of DOCSIS 3.0, which will allow us to offer speeds of 160Mbps or more in the future. Visit the follow URL to learn more about this, and many other initiatives that were presented at this year’s Consumer Electronics Show:
www.comcast.com/ces
Fees
The amount of the fees, specific to new product installation, depends on the promotion and equipment being supplied. I would be happy to review any promotion with you and see if there are alternatives.
Chat Experience
I apologize, if we advertised something to you, we should have honored. Sometimes offers on the web are exclusively through 3rd parties, and you would have to work with that company to receive the promotion. I would be happy to look into that further
Verizon Comparison
I actually know the Verizon product very well, but I typically would not comment on another company’s product. Page loading differences are caused by a variety of issues, from connection speed, route to the website, DNS server information, etc. So it would be difficult to pinpoint the exact cause, but I would be happy to work with you regarding that.
HD Compression
As you are aware, we are constantly striving to provide improved services to our Customers, including a wide variety of HD content. In an effort to do this, we have recently started using a new system to deliver some HD channels. While this system works well with clean 1080i signals, we’re making some adjustments to improve how it handles other types of HD signals so we can bring you the best HD picture. I do apologize that this has not created the HD experience that we intended, but we will work towards getting it right.
Customer Service Improvements
We are doing many enhancements to improve the experience, including hiring additional technicians and Customer Service representatives. We are providing our staff with better tools, including new devices that will perform a 150-point check prior to a technician leaving an appointment. Most importantly, we are improving the training provided to our staff to ensure we provide the best experience during any interaction that we have with our valued Customers. More information regarding these efforts is available at the following URL:
http://www.comcast.com/Corporate/Customers/customercare.html
Besides these enhancements, we are also making it the top priority to listen to our valued Customers. We are doing this in a variety of ways, including our ‘Ask Rick’ program which allows Customers to easily forward feedback regarding their experience with Comcast. We are also visiting Customers around the country to learn from our first hand on how we can improve. To learn more about this, please visit the following URL:
http://www.comcast.com/Corporate/Customers/RickGRoadTrip.html.
I would be happy to discuss all of this with you and I can assure you that your feedback will be shared. Thank you for this, and I look forward to talking further!
Frank Eliason
Comcast Executive Office
215-286-7480
This post is already massive, so I'll reserve my comments to Frank's email for another time. But I'm curious what other people think of Comcast. Anyone have any horror stories or complaints?